Benderson Family Skilled Nursing and Rehab Center
1959 N Honore Ave, ZIP 34235
5 of 5 CMS overall · Much above average
- Inspections5/5
- Staffing5/5
- Quality4/5
- 45 beds
- For-profit
Sarasota, FL · CMS Data August 2026
Highest-Rated Nursing Homes in Sarasota, FL
Where Are the Highest-Rated Nursing Homes in Sarasota?
CMS Care Compare lists 11 nursing homes rated 4 or 5 stars overall by CMS in Sarasota, FL, out of 23 certified nursing homes (data from August 2026). 6 hold the top rating of 5 stars.
- Matching homes
- 11
- All homes in Sarasota
- 23
- Rated 4 or 5 stars
- 11
- Average overall stars
- 4.5
How this list is made: CMS's overall star rating is 4 or 5 (out of 5). The overall rating combines health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Homes are ordered by CMS's overall rating, then its inspection rating.
- 65 stars overall
- 84+ stars for inspections
- 74+ stars for staffing
- 8No fines or payment denials
- 9Antipsychotic use below the national median
- 5Nonprofit
Every Matching Home in Sarasota, With Map
Loading map…
Glenridge on Palmer Ranch Inc.
7333 Scotland Way, ZIP 34238
5 of 5 CMS overall · Much above average
- Inspections5/5
- Staffing5/5
- Quality5/5
- 61 beds
- Nonprofit
- Continuing care community
Hawthorne Center for Rehab &Amp; Healing of Sarasota
5381 Desoto Road, ZIP 34235
5 of 5 CMS overall · Much above average
- Inspections5/5
- Staffing3/5
- Quality4/5
- 120 beds
- For-profit
Pines of Sarasota
1501 N Orange Ave, ZIP 34236
5 of 5 CMS overall · Much above average
- Inspections4/5
- Staffing4/5
- Quality5/5
- 171 beds
- Nonprofit
Sarasota Memorial Nursing &Amp; Rehabilitation Center
5640 Rand Blvd, ZIP 34238
5 of 5 CMS overall · Much above average
- Inspections4/5
- Staffing5/5
- Quality5/5
- 120 beds
- Nonprofit
Sunnyside Nursing Home
5201 Bahia Vista Street, ZIP 34232
5 of 5 CMS overall · Much above average
- Inspections4/5
- Staffing5/5
- Quality5/5
- 60 beds
- Nonprofit
Plymouth Harbor Incorporated
700 John Ringling Blvd, ZIP 34236
4 of 5 CMS overall · Above average
- Inspections4/5
- Staffing3/5
- Quality4/5
- 56 beds
- Nonprofit
- Continuing care community
Pr SNF Operations LLC
5111 Palmer Ranch Parkway, ZIP 34238
4 of 5 CMS overall · Above average
- Inspections4/5
- Staffing3/5
- Quality3/5
- 60 beds
- For-profit
- Continuing care community
Inn at Sarasota Bay Club
1303 North Tamiami Trail, ZIP 34236
4 of 5 CMS overall · Above average
- Inspections3/5
- Staffing5/5
- Quality4/5
- 44 beds
- For-profit
Life Care Center of Sarasota
8104 Tuttle Ave, ZIP 34243
4 of 5 CMS overall · Above average
- Inspections3/5
- Staffing3/5
- Quality5/5
- 120 beds
- For-profit
Sarasota Point Rehabilitation Center
2600 Courtland Street, ZIP 34237
4 of 5 CMS overall · Above average
- Inspections3/5
- Staffing4/5
- Quality5/5
- 120 beds
- For-profit
From CMS Care Compare, data from August 2026. A listing is not an endorsement, and no home pays to appear.
More About This List
Read how CMS star ratings work. For every home in the city, see nursing homes in Sarasota, or highest-rated nursing homes across Florida. For local services, call the Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116.
Other lists for Sarasota: nonprofit nursing homes in Sarasota.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Many Highest-Rated Nursing Homes Are in Sarasota?
11 of the 23 CMS-certified nursing homes in Sarasota, FL meet this rule: CMS's overall star rating is 4 or 5 (out of 5). The overall rating combines health inspections, staffing and quality measures.
Which Highest-Rated Nursing Home in Sarasota Rates Highest?
By CMS's overall rating, then its inspection rating, Benderson Family Skilled Nursing and Rehab Center (5 stars), Glenridge on Palmer Ranch Inc. (5 stars) and Hawthorne Center for Rehab & Healing of Sarasota (5 stars) rank highest. Visit and check the latest inspection report before you decide.
How Do You Check a Nursing Home in Sarasota?
Read its Care Compare page for the full inspection reports, visit at different times, and ask about staffing and openings. Florida's Florida Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program can answer questions about residents' rights.